论文标题

气候危害中的能源不平等:托管和危害引起的停电的社会和空间差异的经验证据

Energy Inequality in Climate Hazards: Empirical Evidence of Social and Spatial Disparities in Managed and Hazard-Induced Power Outages

论文作者

Coleman, Natalie, Esmalian, Amir, Lee, Cheng-Chun, Gonzales, Eulises, Koirala, Pranik, Mostafavi, Ali

论文摘要

美国的能源部门越来越容易受到极端气候危害的影响,导致多次危害引起和管理的停电。据报道,公用事业公司根据停电数量和受影响人群的规模对恢复电力系统的优先级优先。这种方法无法解决不平等的影响。公平基础设施的研究强调,某些人群(例如较低的收入和种族少数民族家庭)受到电力系统中断的影响不成比例地影响。此外,电力系统的连接网络质量提出了空间漏洞的元素。但是,关于能源不平等的存在和程度的经验证据很少。主要障碍是数据收集过程,因为中断数据通常是可腐烂的,并且在颗粒空间尺度上找不到,以允许进行全面的分析。认识到这一重要差距,这项研究收集并分析了与冬季风暴URI(2021)和IDA飓风(2021)有关的观察数据。在冬季风暴Uri的管理中,人口普查区和更多的西班牙裔家庭中间停电持续时间更高。在危险引起的IDA危险中,收入较低的邮政编码和更多的黑人家庭的停电持续时间较高。如空间GINI和基础设施指数分析所示,托管诱导的中断和危害诱导的中断均具有中等水平的空间不平等。这些发现提供了气候危害期间停电中普遍存在的社会和空间不平等的证据,并强调了将公平整合到公用事业经理和紧急计划人员恢复停电的方式中的重要性。

The energy sector in the United States is ever more vulnerable to extreme climatic hazards, leading to multiple hazard-induced and managed power outages. Utility companies reportedly prioritize the restoration of power systems based on the number of outages and the size of affected populations. This approach fails to account for unequal impacts. Research in equitable infrastructure emphasizes that certain populations, such as lower income and racial-ethnic minority households, are disproportionately impacted by disruptions in the power system. Moreover, connected network qualities of the power system suggests an element of spatial vulnerabilities. However, little empirical evidence exists regarding the presence and extent of energy inequality. A main roadblock is the data collection process, in that outage data is often perishable and not found at granular spatial scales to allow the undertaking of a comprehensive analysis. Recognizing this important gap, this study collected and analyzed observational data related to Winter Storm Uri (2021) and Hurricane Ida (2021). In the managed outages of Winter Storm Uri, census tracts with lower income and more Hispanic households had a higher median duration of outages. In the hazard-induced outages of Hurricane Ida, zip codes with lower income and more black households had a higher median duration of power outages. Both the managed and hazard-induced outages had moderate levels of spatial inequality as shown through the spatial Gini and infrastructure index analyses. The findings provide evidence of pervasive social and spatial inequality in power outages during climate hazards and highlight the importance of integrating equity into the manner in which utility managers and emergency planners restore power outages.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源